In an earlier post we discussed how to respond to an unfair labor practice charge and how to respond to union organizing. However, many employees work in unionized work environments and feel that they would be better off without the union.
Some examples are listed here:
- In the Friedrichs v. California Teachers Ass’n decision in 2014 (which resulted in a tie at the Supreme Court), Friedrichs, a California teacher, felt that as a member of a union she was forced to pay dues to the union who used that money to advocate for issues that she did not agree with. Specifically, the union used dues to argue against more parental choice regarding where parents send their kids for school, and the union often spent money to support political causes that she did not agree with.
- Mark Janus, of the Janus v. AFSCME case that went before the Supreme Court, said that he cannot say “No, I don’t want to pay this. I either pay the union fee or I lose my job.”
- Some unionized workers at Kroger have said “I’ve read online about having an initiation fee for the Union but $21 a week for a part-time minimum wage worker seems excessive.”
These are just a few examples of people who feel the union they are associated with does not represent their actual or best interests.
So, what happens if there is already a union in a workplace and the employees no longer want one? There are a couple of ways that employees can get rid of a union if they no longer wish to be represented by the union.
Decertification Election
The most common way that employees choose to no longer be represented by a union is a decertification election.
The decertification process begins when an employee hands the employer a decertification petition that is signed by at least 30% of the employees like this one available through Union Facts.
As stated by the NLRB, decertification petitions cannot be filed in a couple of circumstances:
- These petitions cannot be filed within the first year after a union wins an NLRB sponsored election.
- Plus, if an employer and union reach a collective-bargaining agreement, an employee cannot request “a decertification election (or an election to bring in another union) during the first three years of that agreement, except during a 30-day ‘window period.’” That period begins 90 days before the agreement expires and ends 60 days before the agreement expires (120 and 90 days if your employer is a healthcare institution).
- After a collective-bargaining agreement passes the three-year mark or expires, “employees may request an election to decertify the union or to vote in another union at any time.
Under the National Labor Relations Act, employers cannot provide more than ministerial aid to employees in gathering signatures for a decertification petition. This means that employers cannot give employees aid in circulating the petition or getting employees to sign it. If an employee approaches the employer and asks about getting rid of the union, then the employer can give employees some limited information on how to get rid of the union.
Once a decertification petition is filed, then the employer can actively campaign to get rid of the union, which can include a number of things:
- An employer may hold
meetings to deliver its message. That message must be truthful and must avoid
promises of what will happen if the union leaves or threats.
- There are time limits on when these meetings can be held and typically there is a limit on meetings in the last 24 hours before a vote.
- Employers will often discuss the advantages and disadvantages of a union during these meetings and may compare wages and benefits.
- Employers can state that they want employees to vote against a union.
- It can post flyers with information for employees.
- Supervisors can discuss their experience with the union if they are asked for their opinion.
- Companies can enforce policies about soliciting and distribution of literature during non-working time and in non-working areas (most unionized workplaces will not have such a policy. If that is the case, then both sides may be passing out literature and discussing the union while they are working).
Employers must remember to follow the TIPS protocol (employers cannot threaten, interrogate, promise, or spy) and to avoid other violations of labor law. You can review my earlier article on responding to an unfair labor practice with a breakdown of TIPS and other matters.
NLRB Proposed Rule on Blocking Charges
Unfortunately for many employers and employees, most unions and other employees will file blocking charges to delay a decertification election or to suspend it entirely. Essentially, an employee or the union may file an unfair labor practice charge (alleging that the employer violated the National Labor Relations Act) during a decertification petition and a request to block an election until the unfair labor practice is resolved. This means that unions can continue to represent employees while the charge is being resolved and can sometimes result in an indefinite suspension of the election.
The NLRB has proposed “replacing the current blocking charge policy with a vote-and-impound procedure. Elections would no longer be blocked by pending unfair labor practice charges, but the ballots would be impounded until the charges are resolved.”
This would be a major step that would allow employees to freely decide whether they want to have a union or not. It would also eliminate a common way that unions prevent employees from choosing to leave a union (unions file many charges that prevent an election from ever taking place).
Withdrawal of Recognition
The blocking charge issue can also be avoided by withdrawing recognition from the union. An employer has the option to unilaterally withdraw recognition from a union that has lost support of a majority of the employees in the bargaining unit as held in the Supreme Court’s decision in Allentown Mack Sales & Service v. NLRB. The evidence is usually in the form of a petition signed by a majority of employees that asks for the employer to immediately withdraw recognition from the union. The withdrawal of recognition usually occurs right before the expiration of a collective bargaining agreement or after an agreement has expired.
Typically, collective bargaining agreements have an extension clause whereby the agreement continues unless either party (the union or employer) notifies the other that it intends to terminate or modify the agreement within a certain period of days (typically 60 days) before the agreement expires. It is important that employers send this notice to the union within the required time frame so that the agreement does not continue after it expires.
Unlawful conduct by the employer can result in the union again becoming the bargaining agent for the employees. The typical violations that would prevent the withdraw of recognition are a refusal to bargain with the union before the expiration of the contract, any unlawful (i.e. more than ministerial) assistance in gathering signatures on the petition, or any conduct that unlawfully undermines the union’s majority status.
Withdrawing recognition is usually best for employees and the employer when properly done because it avoids a decertification election, which usually never occurs because unions frequently file unfair labor practice charges that prevent the election from ever taking place. However, due to the complicated nature of union issues, employers are well served by seeking experienced attorneys that can help with this process as an unfair labor practice is almost always filed by the union after an employer withdraws recognition.
Right to Work Laws
Right to work laws do not get rid of the union. They allow individual members to opt out of paying union dues. Essentially, they guarantee that a person cannot be forced, a condition of employment, to join a union or pay union dues. The Janus Supreme Court decision made all government employees in every state subject to this principle. No government employee can be required to join a union as a condition of employment or be required to pay union dues. These employees also cannot be required to pay an agency fee for the union to represent them in the collective bargaining process.
The Janus decision does not apply to private sector employees. A total of 27 states have passed right to work laws that give private employees the right to refuse to join a union or to pay fees for the union to represent them in collective bargaining (agency fees).
Again, the reason why many employees do not want to pay these fees is because the worker may be required to pay for the union to take positions that they oppose. The clearest example of this is new teachers that may be required to pay fees to the union when the union advocates for increased pay raises that result in layoffs of new teachers. See this article and this one this one discussing layoffs that occurred for young teachers as a result of a pay raise and budget shortfall in certain school districts.
Unions still exist in right to work states. A union in these states is still expected to bargain on behalf of all employees including those that are not members of the union. Right to work laws simply allow employees to refuse to pay union dues or agency fees.
Conclusion
Employees that wish to get rid of a union have several options. The best advice for any employee that is looking to leave their union or get rid of a union in their workplace is to look for a petition to get rid of the union (like the one available here) and to speak with their fellow workers that they know would be interested in getting rid of the union. Employees must make sure to do this without violating workplace rules (such as doing it during working time), and they must be careful to avoid speaking with employees that support the union (and the union steward) or having conversations nearby those individuals.
Employees can also approach the company management to let the company know that they (the employee) are trying to get other employees to sign a decertification petition. It is almost always a good idea for the employee to do this so that the employer can alert or find a labor and employment lawyer to help them prepare to respond to any unfair labor practice charge that the union files, to examine the signed petition showing that a majority of employees do not support the union, and to help in any other lawful way that they can.
It is best to act quickly once an employee circulates a petition to get rid of a union. The longer that an employee spends gathering signatures, the more likely it is that the union or union supporters will seek to file an unfair labor practice to block employees that no longer want the union.
The information provided in this blog is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. If you need legal advice, then you should speak with a lawyer about your specific issues. Every legal issue is unique. A lawyer can help you with your situation. Reading the blog, contacting me through the site, emailing me or commenting on a post does not create an attorney-client relationship between any reader and me.
The information provided is my own and does not reflect the opinion of my firm or anyone else.